🤔 Secrets St. James vs Secrets Wild Orchid 🇯🇲🌴

Is Secrets St James or Secrets Wild Orchid better? This is one of the most asked questions we get… and honestly, there’s no simple “just pick St. James” answer 🙃. Both resorts sit side by side in Montego Bay and are nearly identical—just with slightly different vibes & décor.

✨ The Original Idea:

💕 Secrets St. James → Meant for honeymooners & anniversary couples looking for romance.

🎉 Secrets Wild Orchid → Geared toward couples & groups wanting a fun, social, and luxurious vacay.

💡 Reality Check: We see an even split from our clients—both resorts are perfect for:

Jamaica honeymoons 💍🌺
Romantic anniversaries ❤️
Caribbean destination weddings 💒
Incentive & group trips 👯

📞 Call or email Honeymoons, Inc. for special perks + exclusive rates you won’t find online 💸✨

👀 Quick visual tip: the colors are different! St. James = white 🤍, Wild Orchid = cream 🤎.

Let’s look at the resort’s taglines.

Secrets St James

• #Peaceful
• #Sophisticated
• #Paradise

Secrets Wild Orchid

• #Stylish
• #Radiant
• #Fun

My first recommendation is to decide on which one of those taglines fits your personality. The resorts share restaurants and the promenade with shops and nightly entertainment, so you really get the feel that this is one resort not two. To me, this isn’t two 350 room resorts. This is one really nice 700 room resort.

Some of our past guests claim that Secrets Wild Orchid has better views, because it is right on the point of the peninsula, especially the preferred club section. Some of our past guests claim that Secrets St James has a better beach. I personally feel they are so close on beach and views, I wouldn’t make either of these claims.

My second recommendation is see which one prices better for the time you want to go. They are so similar, that I personally would go for the best price.

Secrets Wild Orchid is closer to the promenade and most of the restaurants.

I hope this helps a little. Again, go with the tagline that fits your personality. You cannot go wrong with either resort. Remember, both are adults only all inclusive resorts and are great for honeymoons, anniversaries, groups and Caribbean weddings. These 2 resorts will be found on pretty much every list of top Caribbean honeymoon resorts and top Caribbean wedding resorts.

Also See: Secrets Eternity Honeymoon Package

See Also: Best Secrets Resort for your Honeymoon

Don’t forget we guarantee the best price on Secrets Resorts packages!